CraftedStays
Sign in Get started

Short Term Rental Advocacy I Learned Fighting for Denver Hosts with Dana Lubner

🎙️ Own the Booking and Protect the Right to Take It

“Ambiguity is not an investment strategy.” That line from Dana Lubner reframes how operators should think about short term rental advocacy. You can spend years building a brand and a guest list. Yet one local ordinance can decide whether you are allowed to operate at all. On this episode of the Booked Solid Show, Dana shares how a regulatory fight in Denver turned her into one of the industry’s most trusted organizers. You will learn why waiting for a bad proposal is usually too late and what strong local associations actually do. You will also hear the simple way busy property managers can protect their markets without giving up their evening44

Podcast Summary and Highlights

👋 Meet Dana Lubner

Dana Lubner is the Director of Strategic Partnerships and Industry Relations at Rent Responsibly and Vice President of the Colorado Short Term Rental Association (COSTRA). She entered the industry in 2018 through her brother’s property management company in Denver. When the city weighed rules that threatened local operators, she h4elped start Mile High Hosts and later helped build COSTRA. Today she brings property managers and industry partners into the Right to Rent Collaborative, which funds state and local associations so they can stay active all year. Her goal is simple. Busy operators should be able to protect what they built without becoming full time policy experts.

🏛️ From Feeling Powerless to Earning a Seat at the Table

Dana remembers 2018 in Denver as a scary time. Hosts were facing criminal charges tied to primary residence rules, and the public conversation about short term rentals was overwhelmingly negative. Her strongest memory from that period is a feeling of powerlessness. Then a local host gathered property managers in a competitor’s office with a clear plan: organize, meet with council members, and show that hosts are professional and responsible.

That group hosted the Good Neighbor Summit, invited city staff, and drew seven media outlets. Forming an official association changed how officials received them. One host speaking up is powerful, Dana explains, but a host speaking for an association carries a different level of respect. The group earned positive press and a place on Denver’s Short Term Rental Advisory Committee, where Dana served for a couple of years.

📊 Why Clear Rules Can Be Good for Business

Gil shares his own investor perspective. Early on, mentors told him to avoid markets without strong governance because those are the markets that can flip overnight. His Gatlinburg properties face annual fire inspections and strict safety standards. At first that felt like a nuisance. Years later, he sees it as stability.

Dana agrees. Markets with no rules often attract a sudden surge of listings, followed by concerns about housing, density, and parties. Then the backlash arrives, sometimes as a ban, and operators who bought in are forced to sell alongside everyone else. Her ideal is a fair balance. That means rules that are enforceable, shaped with community input, and consistent with how long term rentals are treated. It is the same patient thinking behind a scalable direct booking strategy instead of a quick win.

🔍 Bring Data to the Conversation

Some rules simply cannot be followed. Dana points to a seven night minimum stay in Santa Fe that left operators with gaps in their calendars and no realistic way to comply. Rules like that push people toward workarounds instead of compliance.

In Virginia Beach, officials kept citing 311 complaint calls as proof of a major problem. The local association filed a Freedom of Information Act request for the call logs. Once the data was reviewed, only a tiny fraction of those calls involved short term rentals. Her lesson is to always ask what problem a rule is trying to solve and what the numbers actually show. A compromise both sides can live with tends to last. A landslide win usually comes back at the next election cycle.

🧯 Build Relationships Before You Need Them

Seven years ago, most calls Dana received came when an ordinance was already at its second reading. By then, she says, the decision is mostly made and officials are simply following due process. Today more groups reach out early. Leaders in Alabama recently told her they are not fighting a fire yet but want to be ready before one starts.

Her core advice is to build the relationship before you need to ask for anything. When officials know you, they know your standards and how much you invest in their community. Great operators already work this way through local business partnerships and with the homeowners they win over through their management page. Trust comes first. The ask comes later.

🤝 Rent Responsibly and the Right to Rent Collaborative

Gil admits he sometimes mixes up the two organizations, so Dana breaks it down. Rent Responsibly provides the administrative backbone for associations, including executive directors, websites, education, and membership systems, so volunteers are not running everything alone. The Right to Rent Collaborative is a separate 501(c)(6) with its own board. It pools money from across the industry and awards grants to state and local associations. It does not lobby or take policy positions itself.

Since launching in early 2025, Dana says the Collaborative has awarded $212,000 through 17 grants to groups representing more than 600,000 short term rentals. Those grants have funded legal support, lobbyists, and six paid executive director roles. Much of that money came from corporate members who see it as insurance for the markets their customers depend on. CraftedStays recently joined that list, and Gil shares why we joined the Right to Rent Collaborative.

💵 One Dollar a Booking Instead of Ten Hours a Week

For years, Dana asked for volunteers, board members, and people willing to show up at city hall. She has burned out as a volunteer herself and watched many others do the same. Asking a busy property manager for ten hours a week rarely works.

The Right to Rent Program offers another path. Property managers on participating systems such as Guesty, Hospitable, Hostfully, OwnerRez, Track, and CiiRUS can opt in to contribute 50 cents, $1, or $2 per reservation. Through Half Stays Local, half of each contribution goes to the state association the manager selects. The other half funds future grants nationwide. You protect your own backyard while helping the industry push back on copycat rules elsewhere. Few managers have ten spare hours a week, Dana notes, but most can spare a dollar per reservation.

🛡️ Direct Bookings Only Work If You Can Operate

This conversation ties straight back to why operators start direct bookings in the first place. Gil recalls that roughly 95% of his first year revenue came from Airbnb, which left him feeling at the mercy of every algorithm change. Past guests like Federico Zimerman and Zachary Humphrey learned that lesson when their listings disappeared.

Dana sees control in two layers. Owning your marketing and bookings is one. Protecting your legal right to operate is the other. All the work you put into building OTA independence means little if a local rule takes away your ability to rent.

📚 Rapid Fire With Dana

Book recommendation: The Four Agreements by Don Miguel Ruiz. Dana keeps its principles printed beside her second monitor: be impeccable with your word, don’t take anything personally, don’t make assumptions, and always do your best. She first read it nearly 20 years ago and plans to reread it every year.

Mindset advice for starting something new: Don’t let fear make the decision. Look three moves ahead and check your blind spots and assumptions. Then commit, fail fast, own it, and learn from it.

One tactical takeaway: Many operators hesitate on direct bookings because of fear. Will it work? Do I need a developer? Dana compares relying on one platform to putting all your savings in a single stock. Rip off the bandage, learn from hosts already doing it well, and take the leap. Then make sure you are also protecting your right to rent.

🔗 Connect With Dana Lubner

Dana Lubner on LinkedIn

Rent Responsibly

Right to Rent Collaborative

Enroll in the Right to Rent Program

Email: dana@rentresponsibly.org

🎧 Listen, Build, and Join the Community

Catch the full conversation with Dana Lubner on the Booked Solid Show, available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube. Ready to own more of your guest relationships? Visit CraftedStays.co to start booking direct. Then come join our community of operators building direct booking businesses together.

Transcription

Dana: I love what you just brought up about this investor angle, because I would say ambiguity is not an investment strategy. I’ve seen so many operators invest in markets where there are no rules. A couple of years ago, I was doing a podcast with Matt Landau, and it became such a pain point for me, because I would see markets that different companies named as great markets to invest in.

Oftentimes those were places with no regulations or very relaxed regulations, and you know they’re going to see a huge surge of short term rentals within those communities. Then the conversation naturally turns toward housing affordability, whether or not it’s caused by short term rentals, the number of short term rentals on a block or within a building, or the sheer number of operators. When you have a ton of operators, the likelihood of more issues and more parties is going to increase.

Gil: Before we bring on our guest, I wanted to talk a little bit about something I’ve been hearing a lot from hosts. I keep hearing the same thing: “I know my website isn’t converting, but I can’t afford $8,000 on an agency to rebuild it.” Here’s the thing. You’re learning all these marketing strategies, you’re driving traffic, and you’re putting it all to work. But if your site isn’t built to convert, you’re basically lighting your energy and money on fire.

And even if you could afford an agency build, every time you want to test something or make a change, you have to pay them again. You can’t iterate, you can’t test, and you really can’t improve. You don’t need a custom $10,000 website to get the conversion rates that matter. You just need the right platform.

That’s why I built CraftedStays. It’s purpose built for short term rentals and designed from the ground up to help you drive more direct bookings. You can finally turn that traffic into bookings, and you can keep testing and improving as you learn. You can make changes right on the platform without learning something new.

So if you need some help or you want to get started, go to craftedstays.co and start your free trial. Now let’s bring on our guest and dive deep into hospitality and marketing.

Gil: Hey, folks. Welcome back to the Booked Solid Show, the show where we bring in top operators to discuss hospitality, operations, and direct bookings.

On today’s show, I have Dana Lubner. She’s the Director of Strategic Partnerships and Industry Relations at Rent Responsibly. She also supports the Right to Rent Collaborative. She’s one of the most impactful people in the industry fighting to keep short term rentals a sustainable option for our guests.

She has helped organize dozens of short term rental advocacy organizations and is on a mission to make sure we can continue to serve our guests. Today, she shares how she got involved in the first place and what property managers can do so that communities and property managers can keep working together to build a sustainable industry.

So without further ado, let’s bring her in.

Gil: Dana, welcome to the show.

Dana: Thanks so much for having me, Gil. It’s a true honor.

Gil: It’s so good to have you here. I think I first met you in Denver. I forget what year it was, but I’m so happy I met you and understood what you were doing. Quite honestly, before you and Dave went on stage, I had no idea what this whole world was about. Could you tee us up with an introduction on who you are and what you’ve been working on?

Dana: Yes. I remember that day. I think it was 2024. I’ve lost track of time, but I do remember that moment. You gave me the warmest welcome. You came up to me, introduced yourself, and we sat down at a table and had a great, deep conversation, which is my favorite type of conversation.

I’ve had, and continue to have, the warmest respect for you, Gil. As for my role in the industry right now, as of this week I’m the Director of Strategic Partnerships and Industry Relations at Rent Responsibly. I’m still working on finessing that mouthful of a title.

I help hosts, property managers, stakeholders, and associations get organized early, build relationships, and create the long term support system they need so they’re not starting from scratch every time a crisis hits.

Gil: You’ve been in this for a long while, so there’s been a recent role change, but you’ve been fighting this fight for years. Talk to me about that journey, how you got started in the first place, and how it has evolved into what you’re doing now.

Dana: I think almost no one intended to start in this industry, so let’s assume that’s a given. I came into short term rentals through my brother Taylor’s property management company in Denver back in 2018. I got to see firsthand how complicated it is to run a property management company.

You have so many competing priorities. You’re trying to keep owners happy. You’re trying to protect revenue. You’re managing a team. I quickly saw that advocacy often ends up at the bottom of a property manager’s list. Back in 2018, that’s when my civic engagement soul was awoken.

Things got really personal in Denver. Hosts were being criminally charged around the primary residence requirement, and the conversation around short term rentals felt incredibly negative. The city was considering rule changes that would affect our ability to keep operating in Denver. In full honesty, it was a really scary time.

It was uncomfortable, and the main word I would circle around is powerlessness. At that point, I didn’t know much about city government, and I didn’t think we had an opportunity to make change. That’s when a host named Joe said, “We need to get all the property managers in Denver together.”

So we met at one of our competitors’ offices, and he said, “Here’s the game plan. We need to organize, we need to meet with city council members, and we need to show that the hosts in our community are professional and responsible.” A couple of months later that year, I met Dave Krauss for the first time when we hosted our first conference, called the Good Neighbor Summit.

We invited city staff to that conference. We had a full room and seven different media outlets. I remember thinking, “Oh my God, they’re actually listening to us.” That was my journey into the work I do now. I started the Denver short term rental association, called Mile High Hosts, which later led me to help build the Colorado Short Term Rental Association.

Within that timeframe, I joined the team at Rent Responsibly, which now takes me into communities across the nation. I started to see the same pattern and the same challenges, and how the same playbook could be incredibly helpful so we weren’t always in a reactive state.

We weren’t always trying to respond to a crisis when it was already too late. The main thing is that people deeply care about advocacy. They deeply care about the future of their businesses. But we were asking a few volunteers to protect an entire industry in their spare time.

That’s the problem I’m working on today with the Right to Rent Collaborative, which is really the solution to what we’ve been trying to solve for the last handful of years.

Gil: In those early days, what was the outcome of all that work in Denver?

Dana: We built a relationship with city council. They knew who we were. First, we launched our organization, so we had professional representation. If you meet with a policymaker or a council member and say, “I’m a host, and I’m just one host,” that’s powerful. But what’s even more powerful is saying, “I’m a host, and I’m part of the Colorado Short Term Rental Association.”

The word association or alliance carries a level of professionalism and respect that we didn’t yet have. It was the classic scenario of a few bad party houses and a few bad actors representing the larger community in an unrealistic and inaccurate way. Having an organization gave us a seat at the table. My chair pin, of course, is here with me today.

We were able to get positive press out. The press had been covering the party houses, the problems, and all the negativity, so we said, “We have to change the story and control the narrative.” Getting positive press out was a really cool moment I’ll never forget. Then we chose to participate in the Short Term Rental Advisory Committee. I sat on that committee for a couple of years. It included people who supported short term rentals, people who did not, a couple of council members, and the city. Together we discussed how the rules were taking shape and what factors to consider when finding solutions for issues that were likely to result in ordinance changes.

So it was a true seat at the table.

Gil: I’ve seen this play out many times in many different markets. I saw it quite a bit as an investor trying to figure out where to purchase our properties. The advice I got over and over again in our very early days of short term rentals was not to go into markets without strong governance, because those are often the ones that can flip either way.

Investors start to gravitate toward markets that have strong standards in place. As I reflect on our conversation, I’ve never seen standards or governance as a bad thing. For instance, we have properties in Gatlinburg, and Gatlinburg is very highly regulated in terms of what you can do.

It has a lot of safety regulations. The fire department comes every single year. Quite honestly, as a property manager, it gives me a lot of comfort that the county and city care so much about our industry and put these rules in place. In the very beginning, as an investor, I thought, “Oh my God, this is a bunch of work.”

We ended up having to change a bunch of things. We had to change our railings, and it was a nuisance at first. But many years into it now, I actually appreciate it, because I know there’s stability there. They have thought about what a good short term rental looks like in their market and what we need to adhere to.

I’m guessing those are the same conversations you’re having in these rooms. Short term rentals aren’t necessarily a bad thing, but let’s understand the concerns on both sides to find the middle ground and figure out what standards need to be in place. I’m guessing standards are a really big part of that conversation.

Dana: I love what you just brought up about the investor angle, because I would say ambiguity is not an investment strategy. I’ve seen so many operators invest in markets where there are no rules. A couple of years ago, I was doing a podcast with Matt Landau, and it became such a pain point for me, because I would see markets that different companies named as great markets to invest in.

Oftentimes those were places with no regulations or very relaxed regulations, and you know they’re going to see a huge surge of short term rentals within those communities. Then the conversation naturally turns toward housing affordability, whether or not it’s caused by short term rentals, the number of short term rentals on a block or within a building, or the sheer number of operators. When you have a ton of operators, the likelihood of more issues and more parties is going to increase.

Then all of a sudden you’ve invested in a community where there weren’t any standards or regulations, no lines to color within. Then you find out the investment is going to be banned or so overregulated, in a way the community had no seat at the table for, that you think, “Okay, now I have to sell.”

Then you’re trying to sell your investment because you can no longer operate, and a handful of other people are trying to do the same. So when we talk about strategy, investment, or prime markets, I’m a big proponent of saying you want to see regulations. You want to have confidence. You want to know what the expectation is.

But it’s about a fair balance of regulations that are enforceable, that have community input, and that respect our current regulations around long term rentals. Do we need to regulate short term rentals in a way that’s different from long term rental activity? There are a lot of conversations going on around the nation right now about where the overreach is.

What’s gone too far? What’s the standard? It’s a topic that’s going to continue, but it’s an important conversation to have.

Gil: You mentioned something, and I don’t know if you used the word equitable. Are there examples of regulations you’ve seen that aren’t equitable or enforceable, and that leave property managers stuck? It’s not that they aren’t allowed to operate, but it makes it very hard to operate to any degree. Do you have any examples of that?

Dana: The first one that comes to mind is one of the first clients we helped with administrative support at Rent Responsibly, the Santa Fe Short Term Rental Alliance. Santa Fe is such a cool community. I recommend that anyone who hasn’t been should go. But they created a regulation where the minimum stay was seven nights. Hard stop.

Anyone who’s an operator is thinking, “Wait, what?” People don’t book a calendar from start to finish. You get a seven night stay in June, then somebody wants to book at the end of May, and suddenly your calendar is blocked off.

There wasn’t a way for operators to comply. Unfortunately, when you have rules like that, whether it’s occupancy limits or the number of stays, you force operators to think, “How can I be creative here?” The last thing we want is to force operators to go underground or out of compliance.

When regulators are considering an ordinance, we have to ask: Is this enforceable? Do we understand the nature of what we’re regulating? Have we brought stakeholders into the room and had conversations about this? What really irks me is regulations that clearly didn’t have community input.

Gil: That’s why I think they probably have a preconceived notion of what they want, and they’re trying to push out short term rentals without understanding how we actually work within those confines. In many cases, short term rentals are good for the community.

They’re good for tourism. They’re good for serving the community. But you have bad actors or incidents that percolate through the media, and then people form a strong association: “I don’t want any of that in our neighborhoods or our markets, so how do we block it altogether?”

That’s what I’m seeing as the driving force behind a lot of these changes.

Dana: I think we’re solving for the wrong problem. Unfortunately, a lot of communities aren’t getting clear on the problem they’re trying to solve or looking at its magnitude. For example, in Virginia Beach, they were talking about creating really strict regulations, and the reason that kept being cited was the calls they were getting to the city.

These were 311 calls to the city, and that was driving the conversation: “What are we going to do? We need to solve this. This is a really big problem.” What we helped the Virginia Beach association do was file a FOIA request, a Freedom of Information Act request, for all of the call logs that go into 311.

Then we went through the data and found that only a tiny percentage of those calls, something like .0028, maybe even smaller, were actually related to short term rentals. It was too many years ago for me to remember the exact figure. Elected officials are trying to solve so many issues, but if you don’t bring data to the conversation, you’ll often find yourself right back in the same position at the next election cycle.

You may also face a lawsuit asking, “Is this actually legal for us to pass in our community?” Housing affordability has become a big scapegoat for why short term rentals need to be banned from communities. I’ve been super curious and trying to learn as much as I can about that conversation, and it’s clear that data isn’t being brought, and solutions that would directly move the needle on housing affordability or housing access aren’t being brought either.

If you follow me on LinkedIn, that’s a lot of what I share, because those articles bring solutions to the table. Banning short term rentals isn’t going to lower rents as dramatically as people expect. It’s also important to always know who’s behind the regulation push.

The classic, biggest example from the last few years is New York City banning short term rentals. What we saw was that hotel rates increased while rents barely moved. So again, the questions are: What problem are we trying to solve, and what data are we bringing to the conversation?

Gil: As we’re talking about this, maybe it’s just me, but I’m very framework driven. When you help a specific market figure out where it stands, there are many different things that come into play.

It sounds like the first is understanding the relationships. Who’s there? Who’s talking? Who’s making decisions? Who’s being vocal? Who has the concerns? Second is understanding the problems being cited.

Third is understanding the data behind those problems. Fourth, once you have all those pieces in play, it becomes a collaboration to figure out where we can meet and how we address those concerns, showing that those voices are heard and then addressing them.

There may be many more pieces to it, but from your perspective, when you look at a market, are those the right pieces? Are there other fundamentals you look at?

Dana: There are a couple of different frameworks, and what you just listed is spot on for the questions to ask when you’re dealing with regulations and you have the golden opportunity to be part of the conversation before proposals reach a second or third reading. Unfortunately, a lot of hosts and operators who didn’t have a state association watching for them found out about regulations when they made headlines in the news.

A property manager is so busy that adding regulation tracking or becoming a policy expert to their to do list isn’t realistic. So that framework is perfect if you’re a member of an association, you have that seat at the table, and you’re joining those conversations where you can ask those questions.

But if a regulation is already at a second reading, or even a first reading, the decision is unfortunately already pretty much made, and they’re just following due process. You touched on something a moment ago: when both sides of the issue concede and compromise to a degree, that is the sustainable outcome.

If you get your way by a landslide, like I said earlier, you’ll probably see the issue keep coming up with each new election cycle. The issue is “never dead,” because election cycles keep happening and new people keep coming into positions, or a new issue pops up and an upset neighbor goes to city council and is relentless.

Keeping in mind that compromise is a path to a win for everyone is the mindset that will really help folks who find themselves in that reactionary mode.

Gil: I’m guessing that’s why there’s such a big emphasis on proactivity. Before things go to a first reading, you’re trying to understand who the decision makers are and which property managers are invested in getting a seat at the table, and you’re trying to build everything before things get hairy.

Is that right? Or is it a balance between that and fighting the fight that’s already happening? Where is your energy going?

Dana: The exciting thing is that seven years ago, I was hearing a lot of reactive calls: “Dana, can you help us? We’re at second reading.” I would say, “I can give you some pointers. I can give you some public testimony comments. I can tell you how to reach out to the media. I can give you some advice on meeting with policymakers.”

But that’s your pull the parachute framework. The incredible thing is that a lot of the conversations I’m having now are different. They’re proactive. I had a conversation with some leaders in Alabama, and they said, “We’ve got some stuff going on, but we’re not in firefighting mode.

We know we need to be ready before the fire comes. So what can we do to professionalize ourselves? How can we build an organization that represents us with the level of professionalism we need to enter a conversation or testify when something does come up?

How do we build the relationships before we need them?” That’s one of the key things I share with advocates and stakeholders: you want the relationship before you need to ask for something. It goes a lot further if they know you. By knowing you, they know your business, the standards you operate by, how much you care, how much you invest, and how you help bolster the community and the economy of the place they govern.

Those are some of the things that have changed in these conversations. Not every group is reaching out with that panic energy. They’ve been hearing, watching, and listening, and they know that the communities that really last, the markets that sustain their ability to operate and grow with confidence, are the ones with a professional association, funding behind it, and the ability to be more proactive than other communities.

Gil: For listeners who may be operating in a market that doesn’t have a professional association yet, what’s your guidance for getting ahead of it and starting that conversation and relationship building?

Dana: That’s the work I do, and the work the team at Rent Responsibly does. Rent Responsibly makes sure you’re not relying only on volunteers to build an association. You have to have volunteers. It has to be an authentic group from the community. There’s no puppeteering. But the reality is you’re probably busy, you probably have a lot on your to do list, and the amount of work it takes to successfully launch an association is more time than most people have.

There are a few unicorns out there, as we call them, who say, “I love this stuff. I’ve done this in other industries. I’m passionate about it, and I have the skill sets.” Those are the people you want on your volunteer board, but it takes time. So Rent Responsibly brings the administrative and back end support to those associations.

It brings on an executive director, a website, education, member value, membership dues, that whole ecosystem, so volunteers aren’t trying to run it all, because it truly becomes a full time job. So reach out to Rent Responsibly. There are so many guides, resources, tools, and recordings I’ve made with the team over the last handful of years that will help you get started and build that framework before you even have to consider how to bring finances into the work. That becomes a really big issue, because we can’t just expect a few volunteers to represent and protect our whole industry.

Gil: As you take a step back, you’ve experienced a lot over almost a decade of building this. Looking forward, do you feel like things are moving in the right direction? Or do you feel like you can’t let off the gas, because as soon as you do, things will slip?

Or do we actually need more horsepower and more people involved, and need to amplify it even more? How do you feel about the impact you and your team have made, and more globally, everyone getting involved? Is it enough, at the right pace, and it’s just about getting the voice out there?

Or do you feel it needs to be amplified?

Dana: I think the reality is both. I feel more hopeful, especially because so much of my energy and day to day work is focused on growing the Right to Rent Collaborative. I feel like we now have a solution we didn’t have before.

We were expecting volunteers to carry this weight. I’ve seen so many volunteers burn out, and I’ve been a volunteer who burned out. I’ve felt this incredible weight that if I stepped away from the organizations I lead, they might cease to exist. That’s so much pressure to put on a volunteer.

I love the work I do because I’m helping people in the roles I’ve lived in and started in, so it feels very personal to me. I feel more optimistic because I think we’ve finally found a solution where there’s a role for everyone to play. Five years ago, you would have heard me saying, “We need volunteers.

We need board members. We need committee members. We need people to show up at city hall.” That’s all still true, but it was unrealistic to ask a busy property manager, with so much responsibility and so many moving parts in a 24/7 business, to dedicate 10 hours a week as a volunteer.

Now we’re in a position where there’s an ecosystem that gives everybody an outlet to plug into. So I feel more hopeful that we can be represented and protect ourselves as an industry globally, and also locally, where a lot of these decisions and discussions happen.

That’s where I think, “Okay, I get it. Asking a busy property manager to give me 10 hours a week is a lost cause.” But now, with things like the Right to Rent Collaborative, a property manager can do their part without giving up their time, and the same goes for the vendors, corporate members, and OTAs within our ecosystem.

Gil: It sounds like you’ve built what you call an ecosystem. You now have the procedures, the tooling, and the playbooks to bring folks together. I suspect you’re continuing to do that in the markets you already serve, and also seeding it with more and more folks so they can get ahead of things and we can keep riding that momentum as you grow.

There’s always going to be a competing force against us. There will always be people outside the industry who want more regulation or want to ban it altogether, so unfortunately it’s always going to be a continual fight. But like you mentioned, you now have a lot more tools that give you that confidence.

Dana: That’s the most rewarding part. Seeing people keep working toward a solution, and I feel like this is where you excel, Gil. You’re listening, you’re watching, you’re looking at the data. You’re not just saying, “This tool works,” when maybe the tool is outdated.

You’re creating and innovating. That’s where I feel our industry finally is. We’ve created and innovated, and now we have an opportunity with a playbook on how to act.

Gil: You mentioned two different organizations, and I don’t know if everybody knows all the parts of Dana and where you contribute. You have Rent Responsibly and Right to Rent. Talk to me about those two organizations and how to think about each one independently.

Quite honestly, I get them mixed up quite often, because they share the same mission of building a very sustainable industry. Talk to me about what the two are, how they differ, and the purpose each serves independently.

Dana: If I’m going to dedicate and volunteer my time and juggle different missions, they need to be synergistic. That’s why I enjoy the fact that, yes, I wear a lot of hats and have a handful of different platforms, but they’re all complementary.

That’s what gets me most excited about the work I do every day. In the simplest terms, the Right to Rent Collaborative brings money together from across the industry and gives state and local associations the money they need to build thriving, sustainable organizations.

The money from the Right to Rent Collaborative goes out as grants, which may help a group hire staff, build relationships, and stay active all year so they’re not starting from scratch every time an issue comes up. That’s the reality. Oftentimes volunteers come together, and once the ordinance proposal passes or doesn’t, everyone says, “I’m so exhausted.

I need to go back to taking care of all the things I’ve neglected.” So the grants give associations the funds to provide year round professional representation and value. Now, it’s very understandable that people get these mixed up, but the Right to Rent Collaborative is its own independent organization.

It’s a 501(c)(6). Rent Responsibly helps manage it, and my role is to bring property managers and industry partners to the Right to Rent Collaborative. The Collaborative has its own board, makes its own decisions, and has an advisory committee. So it’s separate from Rent Responsibly, but Rent Responsibly provides the administrative support.

Gil: So there are different pieces of the puzzle. A heavy part of this is that we can’t do anything without funding and the right resources. The mission of Right to Rent is giving those resources to the associations and the folks on the ground so they can do what they need to do.

Then you have Rent Responsibly, which is all the administrative support and frameworks. Am I thinking about that correctly?

Dana: Absolutely, including the executive director. I’ve volunteered on a handful of boards, and I’ve been on boards with no executive director where, by default, I became the volunteer executive director. That’s usually when things in my personal life start to become compromised, because it’s not sustainable.

With Rent Responsibly’s support, the Right to Rent Collaborative has an executive director and backing for digital representation and marketing, and it sets up the system in a way that makes it easy for stakeholders to participate. One thing I’ll share is that the Collaborative doesn’t lobby or take policy positions.

Its main focus is funding associations doing that work locally. That could be legal support, public education, or hiring a lobbyist for a legislative session. It helps groups that want more of a sustainability mindset, as well as groups in crisis mode when something comes up fast.

Gil: Talk to me about how that funding works. How do you get people involved, and where does the money come from?

Dana: This is the part I love most, because this is where we have outlets for every stakeholder in the industry to plug in. Like I said, you can volunteer, and that’s incredible. We need volunteers in our industry. That’s part of our civic engagement and civic duty, but it’s not realistic for everyone.

I’ll share the progress the Collaborative has made since it launched at the beginning of 2025. So far, $212,000 has been awarded through 17 grants, and those grantee groups represent more than 600,000 short term rentals.

That funding has helped with legal work and lobbyists. It has created six paid executive director roles, which means the people doing the work are doing it as their actual job, not just as volunteers in their spare time. That $212,000 was built up from corporate members.

Think of your Breezeway, your Proper Insurance, your [WISTER, CONFIRM], your PriceLabs. You can go to the website and see who the founding members and current members are. CraftedStays is a new member. Shout out to you. I want to share a little later about the extra step, the extra credit, that CraftedStays has taken.

Those grant funds have been contributed by companies in our industry that know that if short term rental bans pass and markets’ ability to operate is limited, they don’t have customers to sell to. So this is their form of an insurance policy. It’s their way of saying, “We can grow with confidence knowing the markets we operate in are being protected and invested in.”

That was one arm that helped us generate the $212,000 over the last year. The newest arm, launched earlier this year, is the property manager plugin. A property manager using a PMS such as Guesty, Track, Hospitable, Hostfully, CiiRUS, or OwnerRez, with more onboarding right now, can enroll in the program and contribute a small amount per reservation to the Right to Rent Collaborative.

It lets you contribute to the greater cause, play a role, and participate based on the amount you select.

You can select 50 cents per booking, $1 per booking, or $2 per booking. There’s a really cool element of the program called Half Stays Local. If you’re a property manager in Colorado and you enroll at $2 a booking, half of that $2, so $1, goes back to the Colorado Short Term Rental Association, and the other half goes to the Right to Rent grant fund, which becomes future grants for communities across the country.

So what’s in it for me? You’re protecting your own backyard, and you’re also strengthening our voice as an industry. We’ve seen copycat regulations spread, so it’s important to not only look out for yourself, but to ask, “How can we build strength in how we professionally represent ourselves and fight bad regulation across the country?”

That’s the exciting part for me. When I ask a property manager, “Do you have 10 hours a week you can volunteer?” they say, “No.” Then I ask, “Do you have a dollar per reservation?” How a property manager handles it in their books is a conversation for another time, but there are a handful of options to make it work for them.

That’s been the most exciting part of my work right now, seeing property managers say, “This is a no brainer. How could we not? It’s such a small amount. We need to be doing something.”

Gil: We talked about this back in 2024 or 2025 when we first met. I think you were already seeding the idea that you were working on this. Now here we are at the end of 2026, and there’s a lot of momentum. It’s good to hear so many PMSs supporting this behind the scenes.

I’m looking forward to seeing Streamline on there. I’m not sure if that’s going to be the next big one, but I think it will have a big impact, because there are really large property managers in that ecosystem, and many others. A lot of the ones you mentioned, we already support on our side too.

I’m a big fan of it. And like you mentioned, we at CraftedStays wanted to get involved. I don’t remember whether I reached out to you or you reached out to me, but I think it was pretty mutual. As the founder of CraftedStays, I wanted to get involved, and I felt it was so important.

Just like you mentioned, without sustainability in our industry, our company would not exist over time. For us, it’s a very small contribution overall. You call it insurance, but I don’t know if it’s making as big an impact as it could.

We should be investing more, and that’s why I’m a big proponent of getting the news out there. Yes, it’s partly about corporate giving and giving back to the industry. But I think there’s a bigger thing in sharing our voice and making this much more visible, because a lot of folks don’t know how to get involved, whether anything is already in place, or whether they should get involved.

Going back to the hopefulness, I think one of the biggest things I’ve seen over the last few years is that there’s now a lot more structure in place that allows property managers and other industry leaders to figure out how they fit into all of this.

You mentioned a really good point: some people have time, some people have money, and there’s a way for everyone. If someone has a heart for this, they’re going to get involved. If you give them the right options, and those options are attainable, they’ll get involved.

I’m unfortunately not part of any of these associations, but I am the executive vice president of our school PTA, and I know how hard it is to get volunteers. When you mention volunteer burnout, we see a lot of it in the PTA, because a small group of parents is working really hard to deliver the best experience for our students. We’re very involved, and we put on a lot of activities.

But after a couple of years, we burn out, and then we cycle in the next parent to take the reins. Over time, we’ve also recognized that not every parent is going to get involved, and fundraising is another big part of it. Some people just don’t have the time.

They’re being pulled in many different directions, and they can contribute better through funding, helping us pay for some of the programs and activities we want to run. So as you talk about this, even though I’m not a board member in any of these markets, as a PTA member I empathize with the struggle it takes to run these organizations and figure out how to engage the community when they want to be engaged.

Dana: The PTA is a perfect example. You’re on the PTA because you probably have a kid in the school system, and what do you care about more deeply than that? That’s how I think about the advocacy side of the short term rental industry.

It was never a matter of people not caring. People care deeply. You do everything to grow your business. You’re booking direct, you’re keeping your owners happy, you’re making revenue, you’re growing your portfolio. But if you’re not watching the advocacy part, that’s the gotcha.

You can lose your whole portfolio because you’re not participating. It’s important to remember that just because you can’t volunteer your time doesn’t mean it’s the only option, and it doesn’t mean you don’t care. You need to be realistic. There’s nothing more challenging than a volunteer I’ve pressured into the role who can’t show up to any meetings, or who comes with ideas but doesn’t take any ownership.

They don’t understand the idea of a working board. That used to put people in a position of volunteer or nothing. Now it’s: you don’t have to volunteer, but you’ve got to do something. Before we move on, I want to give a shout out to CraftedStays, because you deserve some real credit.

You were such a supporter of this from the moment we spoke. You didn’t just become a corporate member of the Right to Rent Collaborative and put the badge in your website footer. You built a whole page that explains why this matters, how property managers can take part, and where to enroll. That’s going the extra mile.

That’s not a company saying, “Well, I feel guilty saying no.” That’s a company that really believes in the mission. There’s one line on the page that says it all: “Our customers can only book direct if they can operate.” You’re using your platform and your relationships with property managers to bring more people into this work. That’s what real partnership looks like, and I want to thank you for the effort you’ve put into taking it beyond the membership and building something so thoughtful around it.

Gil: Like I mentioned earlier, I feel like it’s a very small part. The corporate giving we did is a small part of a really big fight, and it’s not going to be won by Breezeway, PriceLabs, and the rest of us simply giving money.

It takes a lot, and much of it comes down to visibility and getting people involved. That’s why I wanted you to join our town hall and talk with our existing customers, to give them that visibility. I want to keep doing more, because I think this is a really big fight.

I’ve seen what you, your organization, and many others in this industry have been doing, and I’m just trying to do my part the best way I can. For me, using each of our platforms to raise awareness is one of the most effective ways I can contribute.

Dana: I just want to put in a request for 10 more Gils and CraftedStays out there.

Gil: If you’re in the industry and you’re serving property managers, please reach out to Dana. And if you’re a property manager, you should be getting involved. Educate yourself, see whether there’s already a board in your area, and find out how to get involved.

Find out what the regulations are, and reach out to you folks, Dana. Again, I think we need to do more and keep fighting. I appreciate you dedicating your time. You’re a blessing for the industry, you and Dave Krauss. The things you’re doing are amazing.

I think we’ve taken a lot of this for granted. You’re fighting a really big fight, and you need more firepower and a bigger army behind you. That’s why we’re getting involved.

Dana: Thank you for the kind words. I feel like we’re starting to move in that direction, and it feels incredibly encouraging. It’s giving me more wind in my sails to keep doing this work I care so deeply about.

Gil: It’s hard work. It’s really, really hard work.

Dana: Sometimes it feels like crazy work, because you think, “We’re not getting anywhere, our framework is outdated.” But we don’t have to reinvent the wheel. The Right to Rent Collaborative borrowed from what the hotel lobby was doing so we wouldn’t have to start from scratch.

That’s what’s really encouraging. If the hotel lobby is what we’re up against in some markets, then we need to think like the hotel lobby.

Gil: Looking back at some of your accomplishments over almost a decade now, what are you most proud of?

Dana: Well, an opportunity to toot my own horn. I’d say seeing myself become an advocate for a cause. When I took a job with my brother at his property management company, I never thought this would be my life seven years later.

Seeing myself find so much passion for a cause, and not lose hope. I hear from so many people, whether we’re talking about the political landscape or short term rental regulations, who think they don’t have a voice, that their voice doesn’t matter, and ask, “Why should I care?

It’s already a lost cause.” So seeing that change within me, and then sharing that light with others in our industry, means a lot. I have a handful of board members and short term rental advocates across the industry who tell me, “I went with you to my first city hall,” or, “You and I went and testified against a bill, and I had never been in that building before.”

It was so cool to see them light up the way I did. Being able to share my light with others and see it spark within them is, without a doubt, the most rewarding accomplishment of these last seven years.

Gil: That’s awesome. Dana, it’s been a huge pleasure. We usually end the show with three questions. First question: what’s one book that has inspired you throughout your career or your life?

Dana: Right now I’m into sci fi fantasy, and maybe you could call some of it smut, so I won’t bring up one of those books. But I’ve become a reader. If you’d asked me this question 10 years ago, I might not have had an answer. I wanted to pick up a hobby outside of short term rental advocacy, because my husband said, “You don’t have any hobbies.

Your work is your hobby.” And I said, “Shots fired.” So I decided to become a reader. I now read about 30 books a year, and these are long books. I’m just like, “Who am I?” It’s such a fun way to use your imagination. But for the sake of this podcast, I’ll share a book I read recently that was inspired by a conversation with Darren Petitjean from [WISTER, CONFIRM].

He brought up this book, and I said, “Oh my God, I read this book close to 20 years ago.” I found my signed copy from my dad. It’s The Four Agreements, and it’s a thin book, so even if you’re not a reader, you can still read it. I have the principles printed out on my second monitor because I want to remember them always.

They are: be impeccable with your word, don’t take anything personally, don’t make assumptions, and always do your best. I love those as guiding principles, because it’s so easy to get caught in a thought pattern, make assumptions, or be tempted to say something that isn’t in alignment or authentic to you.

I love those simple principles, and the book is written so simply that I think I’ll read it every year moving forward.

Gil: I need to run through those four again in my head, so I’m going to look it up after our interview. That’s amazing. Second question, Dana: what’s one piece of mindset advice you would give to someone starting something completely new?

Dana: You said one, but I’m going to go with two. Fear stops me from doing so many things. It’s something I don’t want to admit, but let’s be real. What could we do if we had no fear? For anyone old enough to remember the No Fear era and the shirts.

Gil: Yeah.

Dana: Not to be reckless, but these two tie together. What I’ve been practicing right now, which I think is helpful, is looking three moves ahead. When you’re making a decision, whether you’re workshopping it or brainstorming with AI or partners, look three moves ahead. Look out for blind spots.

What assumptions are we making here? Then think about how it plays out 10 minutes from now, three years from now, and five years from now. But don’t let fear stop you from making a decision and failing. The most successful people are the ones who have failed.

They’ve experienced failure, owned it, and learned from it, which gives them that much more wisdom and helps them be more fearless in the future.

Gil: You had a second one as well?

Dana: I think I did three in one. No fear, look three moves ahead, and fail often, fail fast, and learn from those lessons.

Gil: Awesome. I think back to when I first started this company three years ago. We’re crossing our anniversary soon. I remember leaving my W2 job and wondering whether I could do this and whether I should. A lot of people, like my [SDR/STR, CONFIRM] mastermind peers, pushed me into it.

But in the back of my mind, it was very comfortable being in that W2 job, so I went through a fear setting exercise. Instead of goal setting, I did fear setting to figure out the worst that could happen. I think that’s probably very similar to looking three moves ahead.

I had to figure out, “Okay, if this doesn’t go well, we have our short term rentals, and they’re cash flowing. We have our savings.” Going through that gave me a lot of confidence. The safety net we’d been building was actually pretty safe. There was no good reason not to do this.

I had enough fire to do it, and I’m really glad I overcame that fear, because I grew so much in the first year of starting the company, and I continue to. Had I stuck with my W2, my life, my personality, my character, and my capabilities would have been dramatically different. I’m proud to have built this company and made an impact on our industry.

I’m so glad I went through what you described, that fear setting, really thinking, “Okay, I can do this,” and psyching myself into it.

Dana: Like asking yourself, “What’s the worst that can happen?” I’m so proud of you for taking that leap of faith. You’ve built a life you love and enjoy. So many people get stuck in jobs thinking they’re safe. But what fun is there in playing it safe?

Gil: I won’t trivialize it. At first it was extremely hard. But once you get past the really hard points, and there’s always going to be another one, it’s actually quite rewarding. You just need to grind through it.

Behind my monitor there’s a poster that says “grit,” and it reminds me not to give up on the things I care about.

Dana: I love that.

Gil: Last question, Dana. What’s one tactical takeaway our listeners can put into practice today to either get started with direct bookings or amplify their direct bookings?

Dana: From my seat in the stands, when I have direct booking conversations with property managers or operators, I hear things like, “Does that really work?” “How easy is it for me to actually do that?” “Do I need a developer?” “Am I actually going to get any bookings from this?”

I think that’s fear speaking. That’s what’s preventing you from giving yourself the opportunity to create a direct booking business, create autonomy, and avoid platform codependence or reliance. Avoiding that dependence is smart. When someone gives you guidance on investing your portfolio, you wouldn’t put all of your investments in one stock.

You want to diversify. So if you consider yourself a smart operator, or you want to become a smart or strong operator, I’d say rip off the bandage. Learn as much as you can, talk to other hosts who are doing it successfully, learn the tactics you can deploy so you can say this is worth your investment, and then take the leap.

Have no fear, and look at the upside. All of that matters when you’re thinking about how to make your business successful, sustainable, and here in the future, because there are a lot of changes outside our control. But I’d also add that none of it matters if a local rule takes away your ability to operate.

So make sure you’re also protecting your right to rent, not just the business you’ve done so much work to build.

Gil: I agree. For me, it’s really about sustainability. The biggest driver for starting this company in the first place was to give property managers the tools to be independent and sustainable, because I felt like I had too many eggs in one basket as a property manager.

We were meeting our revenue goals, but about 95% of our revenue in that first year came from Airbnb. I felt that if they changed anything, I’d be at their mercy. This was before all the changes they made in 2025, and even more so in 2026. Those were the golden years, and they were already making algorithm changes.

That’s why I want to involve myself in what you’re doing. We’re here to build very sustainable businesses. Yes, we’re here to make money and deliver returns for our homeowners, but we also want to build a very sustainable business.

For me, one part is having control over your own marketing and bookings, and the other is making sure you can continue to operate indefinitely. These are things you have to nurture over a long period of time. It’s not a little sprint where you do a bit and stop.

You have to make a concerted effort and nurture these things if you want a very sustainable business.

Dana: And don’t give up. Some advice I heard is that if you’re going to complain about an issue and you’re not in the room or finding a solution, you’re just complaining, and the world doesn’t need more complainers. Thank God you saw that as an issue and did something about it, which is what you’re doing today.

Whenever I see you putting out education and sharing insights, you’re seeing an issue you experienced yourself and saying, “I want to be part of the solution.” When you built CraftedStays for the challenge you faced with 90% of your bookings coming through one platform, thank God we have Gils out there who have created opportunities for us to actually do something about it.

That’s how I look at my work. I’m giving you a solution. We don’t just have to complain about an outcome or bad regulations. We need to find the people who have created solutions, support them, and play our part.

Gil: Awesome. I love it. Dana, for folks who want to stay in touch with you and get involved, where can they find you?

Dana: For Right to Rent, the website is r2rcollaborative.org. Whether you’re a vendor, a property manager, or a host who just wants to make a $10 contribution per month, there’s literally something for everyone. If you’re an operator and you want to start an association, go to rentresponsibly.org.

That will give you a massive library of free tools and resources. Or if you’re running an association and thinking, “If I step away, this thing will fall apart. I can’t keep doing this,” you can learn about the services that groups across the country are contracting Rent Responsibly for.

If you want to send me an email, you can reach me at dana@rentresponsibly.org, or you can follow me on LinkedIn.

Gil: Awesome. Dana, thank you for fighting the good fight. I can’t wait to keep seeing you make an impact on the industry as a whole. Keep on fighting.

Dana: And you keep on fighting, keep spreading the word, and keep doing what you’re doing, Gil. This has been a true honor. Thank you so much for having me.

Gil: Thank you, Dana. Bye.

Dana: Bye bye.

Scroll to Top