Social Media Marketing for Short-Term Rentals: Building a Brand That Books Directly with Emily Lethgo
Most hosts launch a direct booking site and then wait. They post occasionally. They hope something goes viral. And when bookings don’t come, they quietly go back to Airbnb. Emily Lethgo built something different — and she did it in the Smoky Mountains, one of the most competitive short-term rental markets in the country. Starting with a single cabin and a marketing background, she spotted a gap that most operators still haven’t filled: the space between having a great property and actually getting people to discover it. In this episode of the Booked Solid Show, Emily shares how she went from a Facebook post offering to photograph 10 cabins for free, to building Matchpoint Socials — a boutique, full-service marketing agency working exclusively with short-term rental brands. She opens up about what consistency really looks like in practice, why a viral post is actually the worst thing to chase, how she structures her team so every client gets five specialists instead of one overloaded generalist, and what she tells hosts who are wondering whether social media is actually worth the effort. If you’ve ever felt like you’re doing all the right things but not seeing traction — this one’s for you. Summary Highlights 👤 About Emily Lethgo Emily Lethgo is the founder of Matchpoint Socials, a boutique social media marketing agency built exclusively for experience-led short-term rental brands. Based in Knoxville, Tennessee, Emily and her seven-person team serve as a full outsourced marketing department for vacation rental operators who want consistent visibility — without having to figure it all out themselves. Her journey into this niche wasn’t planned. After purchasing a cabin in the Smoky Mountains in 2021, Emily started sharing the journey on social media the way she naturally knew how — through her marketing background. Within weeks, she had an email list of people asking to be notified when the cabin went live. That moment crystallized something important: hosts were building beautiful properties but leaving the demand-generation piece almost entirely to Airbnb. She started with a bold move — posting in a Smoky Mountain STR Facebook group and offering free content creation to 10 hosts. Over 50 people responded. She handpicked her portfolio, spent the next month visiting properties, and the rest, as she puts it, just took off. Today, Matchpoint Socials offers a full suite of services: organic social media management, paid ads, email marketing, and influencer coordination. Emily’s team structure is intentional — one graphic designer, one social media manager, one strategist, and specialists in each lane — so every client gets a focused team rather than a stretched-thin generalist. You can connect with Emily at: 🔗 Instagram: @emilylethgo | @matchpointsocials 🌐 Website: www.matchpointsocials.com 🔑 Key Takeaways from This Episode 🚫 Stop Chasing Virality — Start Building a System One of Emily’s most grounding pieces of advice: virality is exciting, but it’s not a strategy. She’s watched clients go viral and still not see a meaningful uptick in bookings — because the foundation wasn’t there to capture it. What actually works? Showing up consistently. Every week. With posts that have a clear hook, a clear call to action, and a specific person in mind. As Emily puts it, every post should have a purpose. If you can’t answer “who am I talking to right now and what do I want them to do?” before you hit publish — it’s not ready. This connects directly to what so many hosts discover when they start working on social media content strategies that drive direct bookings: consistency compounds. A viral post is a spike. A system is a slope. 📐 Quality Over Quantity — Always Emily pushes back hard on the idea that more content equals more results. She’d rather a host publish 12 intentional, well-crafted posts per month than 30 rushed ones. The goal isn’t volume — it’s impact per post. This is especially important for hosts managing everything themselves. The pressure to post daily is real, but it often leads to content that doesn’t convert. Emily’s team evaluates every piece of content through a simple lens: does this make someone stop scrolling, feel something, and take action? If the answer is no, it doesn’t go out. 🎯 Know Your Ideal Guest Before You Create Anything Before you open your camera or type a caption, you need to know who you’re creating for. Emily makes this clear to every new client: the content strategy is only as strong as the clarity around the guest avatar. This shapes everything — the hook, the format, the platform, the tone. A property targeting romantic couples in the mountains is going to look and sound completely different from one targeting large family reunions. When you write to everyone, you reach no one. Copywriting for direct booking sites follows the same principle — and so does every post that’s going to send traffic to that site. 📈 The Marketing Channels That Actually Compound Emily’s agency has evolved well beyond posting. Over the past year, she’s expanded into three core add-ons that she now sees as essential pillars of a complete direct booking strategy: Paid Ads: Organic is the foundation, but ads amplify what’s already working. Emily encourages hosts to get their organic content performing first — then layer in paid spend to accelerate reach. Email Marketing: This is where the long game really pays off. Unlike social media, where reach is algorithm-dependent, an email list is owned. Every subscriber is someone who raised their hand. Emily’s team tracks click rates and engagement closely, making email one of the most measurable channels they manage. If you want to understand how email fits into a broader direct booking strategy, the complete guide to collecting guest emails is worth reading. Influencer Coordination: What makes Matchpoint Socials’ approach different here is the Rolodex model. Instead of one-off partnerships, Emily’s team builds ongoing relationships with vetted influencers. When a new client needs one, she already knows who’s a fit, what they’ve delivered, and what to expect. Unique










