Guest Data Collection that Drives Direct Booking Revenue through StayFi with Arthur Colker
“As long as you’re providing value, hopefully your marketing will be mostly perceived generously and people will want to receive it.” What if the key to competing with major OTAs wasn’t just about building a better website—but capturing data from every single guest who stays at your property? Arthur Colker, Founder & CEO of StayFi, discovered this truth while helping a New Orleans property manager escape 99% OTA dependency. In this episode, he shares how a WiFi-based data capture solution evolved into a full guest marketing platform powering direct bookings across vacation rentals, boutique hotels, and hospitality brands. Arthur reveals why guest data ownership is the biggest missed opportunity in short-term rentals, how diversifying channels matters more than eliminating OTAs entirely, and the groundbreaking StayFinder meta-search tool launching soon that will let travelers compare direct booking prices against major platforms. Whether you’re managing 2 properties or 200, Arthur’s insights on guest data strategy and the evolving hospitality tech landscape will reshape how you think about building an independent brand. Summary and Highlights 🎯 Meet Arthur Colker Arthur Colker is the Founder and CEO of StayFi, a guest marketing platform that started as a WiFi data collection tool and evolved into a comprehensive solution for vacation rentals, boutique hotels, and independent hospitality brands. Since 2018, Arthur has been helping property managers capture guest data and build independent booking channels that reduce reliance on major OTAs. Before StayFi, Arthur worked as a marketing consultant across various industries. His entry into short-term rentals happened almost accidentally when he took on a vacation rental operator as a client and discovered they had zero guest data despite managing 200 properties. That gap became the genesis of StayFi—a platform now used by thousands of operators who understand that guest data ownership is the foundation of a resilient, profitable hospitality business. Arthur is passionate about helping independent operators compete with major platforms, not by undercutting them, but by building their own brands and creating direct relationships with guests. His latest project, StayFinder, aims to make direct booking discovery as easy as booking through an OTA—while delivering real savings to travelers. 💡 Key Takeaways ✅ Guest data is the most overlooked asset in short-term rentals — Most operators collect names and emails only from bookers, missing everyone else in the reservation✅ Direct booking isn’t about replacing OTAs — It’s about channel diversification and building a resilient business that isn’t dependent on one platform✅ Marketing works when it delivers value — Position direct booking as a “secret” that saves guests money, not just a way to avoid fees✅ Your property needs to rank on Google — If someone searches your listing name and can’t find your direct site on page one, you’re losing bookings✅ Unique property names matter for SEO — Generic names like “Cozy Creek Cabin” make it nearly impossible to rank and be discovered✅ Founders need conviction, not just optimism — Arthur calls it “delusional self-belief,” but you also need to listen when customers tell you what’s not working🏠 How StayFi Started: Solving One Client’s Problem Arthur didn’t set out to build a hospitality tech company. He was doing marketing consulting for various businesses when he landed a short-term rental operator called Heirloom, managing around 200 properties across New Orleans, Boston, and Scottsdale. Their goal was simple: build a brand identity and figure out how to get guests to book directly. The challenge? They were 99% dependent on Airbnb for bookings and had zero guest data. No names, no emails, no phone numbers. Arthur realized that acquiring new guests is expensive and trust-dependent. The easiest path to direct bookings would be marketing to people who already stayed and loved the properties. But how do you market to ghosts? He looked for existing solutions—captive portal systems used in cafes, airports, and hotels. Nothing worked well for single-family vacation rentals. So he built a custom solution using white-labeled hardware and a basic splash page that collected marketing consent when guests logged into WiFi. V1 of StayFi was scrappy. No customer portal. No self-service. Arthur manually configured everything for each client. But it worked. And when he looked around the industry, he realized the problem was universal. That’s how StayFi was born. 📈 The Evolution: From WiFi to Full Guest Marketing Platform The early years were a grind. Through 2019, StayFi was still a part-time project. Then Arthur went full-time—right as the hardware partner got acquired and pricing became unfeasible. He had to rebuild the tech stack while simultaneously dealing with COVID shutting down his 10-15 paying customers overnight. But instead of folding, Arthur used the downtime to build StayFi’s first self-service portal and flash page builder. By the time short-term rentals roared back in 2021, the platform was ready to scale. Timing couldn’t have been better—hosts were angry at Airbnb for how they were treated during the pandemic, and the industry was hungry for tools that reduced OTA dependence. Fast forward to today, and StayFi has evolved far beyond WiFi data collection. The platform now includes: 🔹 Homepage Tool — A link-tree-style page for guests that consolidates all the resources they need during their stay🔹 Email Marketing Software — Purpose-built for vacation rentals, not generic tools like MailChimp🔹 PMS Integrations — Pulling data from property management systems to create a unified guest database🔹 Upsell Amplification — Helping operators present offers like early checkout, mid-stay cleans, and local experiences to all guests, not just bookers The guiding principle? Collect guest data from every touchpoint, then help operators monetize that data—whether through rebookings, upsells, or entirely new revenue streams. For property managers who also run real estate businesses, tour companies, or retail shops, StayFi has become a powerful cross-marketing engine. Guests who stay in vacation rentals are often the same people who later buy properties in that market. The data becomes invaluable. 🔍 StayFinder: The Next Frontier in Direct Booking Discovery Arthur’s newest project, StayFinder, tackles a different problem: guest discovery. Most direct booking tools focus on converting existing traffic