Guest Favorite Over Superhost: What’s Actually Moving the Airbnb Algorithm with Dan Rivers
“Take the cheat code — go find someone who’s done it, who’s done it well, and learn from them.” — Dan Rivers If you’ve been thinking about revenue management as a single lever you pull once in a while, this episode is going to shift your perspective. Dan Rivers has been in real estate since 2005, navigating everything from high-rise condo management on the beach to flipping homes to building a thriving short-term rental portfolio — and he’s learned most of it the hard way. Today, as co-founder of SynergyStays, a revenue management company serving STR operators in the U.S. and Mexico, Dan brings a no-fluff, results-first approach to how operators think about revenue, occupancy, and direct bookings. In this episode of Booked Solid, Dan and Gil go deep on what it actually takes to stop being just “good” and start being great at running a short-term rental business. You’ll hear how Dan transitioned from acquiring more and more doors to building a scalable business designed around his lifestyle, why revenue management is far more than nightly pricing, and how pushing your clients toward direct bookings is becoming a non-negotiable part of any solid revenue strategy. Summary and Highlights 👤 About Dan Rivers Dan Rivers is the co-founder and Business Development Manager at SynergyStays, a short-term rental revenue management company helping investors and property managers maximize profitability. With nearly 20 years in real estate, Dan has facilitated over $100 million in transactions spanning traditional sales, fix-and-flips, long-term rentals, commercial properties, and short-term rental management. His background spans large-scale property management on the beach to high-rise condo portfolios, and he’s since channeled that experience into building a revenue-focused company alongside partners Mike and Jake. Beyond real estate, Dan is a devoted family man, an avid world traveler, and someone who deeply believes in building a business that works with his life — not the other way around. He’s operated in markets across the U.S. and Mexico, and SynergyStays currently serves operators from Charleston, South Carolina to Pittsburgh and beyond. 🔑 What You’ll Learn From This Episode 🏗️ From Shiny Object Syndrome to Strategic Focus Dan’s journey through real estate mirrors a path a lot of operators recognize. He’s done flips that netted a million dollars and flips that cost him $80,000. He’s chased strategies he found on BiggerPockets and learned — sometimes painfully — that chasing everything often means mastering nothing. His word of the year is “focus.” And that wasn’t an arbitrary choice. It came after years of spreading across multiple strategies, being good at many things but never great at any single one. What changed was recognizing that true scale comes from identifying where you add the most value and going all in there. For Dan, that place is revenue management. His partner brings over a decade of experience in the craft, and Dan brings the business development engine. Together, SynergyStays positions itself as the golden shovel — not the one digging for gold, but the one everyone who’s digging needs. 📊 Revenue Management Is More Than Pricing This is the part of the conversation most operators need to hear. When Gil and Dan talk about revenue management, they’re not talking about setting a minimum nightly rate and letting dynamic pricing do the rest. SynergyStays takes a comprehensive approach that includes: Cancellation policies — Dan points out that overly strict policies are quietly hurting operators. If you’re heavily reliant on OTAs, a stringent cancellation policy affects your search algorithm placement, which directly impacts your occupancy. Loosening your policy can feel like a risk, but it often opens up more booking opportunities than it closes. AB testing listing elements — Photos, titles, descriptions, and length-of-stay minimums are all tested and iterated on a regular basis. Every Monday, the SynergyStays team reviews what booked over the weekend, what could have been priced better, and what they want to test next. Weekday occupancy strategies — Dan shares how his team identified open weekdays across their client portfolio in January and built a specific strategy around them. The result? An 18% year-over-year increase in weekday occupancy for March — booked 30 to 45 days in advance, not last minute with heavy discounts. Guest ratings as a revenue lever — Every 0.1% drop below a 5-star rating can cost an operator up to 10% in revenue potential. That’s not a number to ignore, especially as Airbnb’s algorithm continues to evolve. If you want to go deeper on how listing optimization and OTA positioning affect your overall performance, this piece on vacation rental marketing strategies is worth reading alongside this episode. 🌟 Superhost Is Out. Guest Favorite Is In. Here’s something a lot of operators haven’t caught on to yet: Superhost is no longer the primary signal Airbnb’s algorithm is rewarding. Dan and his team are seeing a clear shift toward Guest Favorite as the badge that actually moves the needle on search placement and bookability. What goes into Guest Favorite? It’s not as simple as a high star rating. Dan and Gil walk through what they’re observing: This is exactly why relying on any single signal is risky. The algorithm is always moving. You need someone — whether that’s a revenue manager or yourself — actively watching it. And as Dan points out, if your direct booking volume starts pulling guests away from Airbnb for stretches of time, that could affect your visibility there too. It’s a balance worth managing intentionally, not accidentally. For more context on how Airbnb’s policy changes are reshaping the landscape for operators, check out this breakdown of Airbnb’s 2025 changes. 📧 Orphan Nights, Email Lists, and the Direct Booking Advantage This is where the conversation gets really tactical. Dan and Gil both operate in a world where OTA dependency is a risk, not a strategy. One of the clearest examples they discuss is orphan nights — those one or two open days sandwiched between existing bookings. On an OTA, filling orphan nights usually means racing to the bottom










