CraftedStays
Sign in Get started

Where Property Managers Beat OTAs in AI Search, Stage by Stage

When a guest asks an AI engine about a trip, the answer cites a handful of websites. For a property manager, the real contest is with the OTAs. So we measured that contest directly, at every stage of the trip, on five engines.

This article is one of the deep dives behind our guide to AI search for vacation rentals. It comes from our study of 19,950 AI answers to 1,330 traveler questions across 50 US vacation markets, November 2026.

This is a snapshot from November 2026. AI engines change fast, so treat these numbers as a read on the moment, not a permanent rule.

Who do AI engines cite at each stage of a trip?

A guest does not ask one question. They ask where to go, what to do, which area to stay in, which company to book, which home fits their group, and what it costs on their dates. We asked all of those, in all 50 markets, and sorted every cited website into a category.

Who AI engines cite at each stage of a trip

Each stage adds to 100% of the sources the engines cited, each engine weighted equally.

Property managersOTAsNational rental brands and travel search sitesHotels, resorts, innsTravel blogs and mediaTourism boards and governmentAttractions and local businessesSocial sites and forumsOther
Where to go
12%49%9%
Things to do and trip planning
10%28%29%10%
Which area to stay in
9%18%29%14%14%
Which company or kind of place
36%21%11%
A home for my group
31%30%13%
Several needs stacked in one ask
19%50%13%
Dates or a budget
41%34%14%
Long, the way guests talk
18%44%10%8%
See the numbers
StageProperty managersOTAsNational rental brands and travel search sitesHotels, resorts, innsTravel blogs and mediaTourism boards and governmentAttractions and local businessesSocial sites and forumsOther
Where to go5%12%8%3%49%5%4%9%5%
Things to do and trip planning10%6%4%4%28%29%6%10%2%
Which area to stay in9%18%7%5%29%14%4%14%1%
Which company or kind of place36%21%7%3%7%6%2%11%7%
A home for my group31%30%13%5%6%4%2%7%1%
Several needs stacked in one ask19%50%13%4%2%3%1%5%2%
Dates or a budget41%34%14%2%2%3%1%2%0%
Long, the way guests talk18%44%10%8%5%4%1%8%1%

Base: 123,695 citations from 19,950 answers, five engines, 50 markets. November 14 to 16, 2026. A snapshot; AI answers change.

The engines hand each stage to a different kind of website:

  • Where to go: travel blogs and media take 49% of citations. Property managers get 5%.
  • Things to do and trip planning: tourism boards take 29% and travel blogs 28%. Property managers get 10%.
  • Which company or kind of place: property managers lead with 36%.
  • Dates or a budget: property managers lead with 41% (each engine weighted equally).

What it means: “AI search” is not one contest. Early in the trip, property managers are a small slice of the answer. Once the guest starts shopping for a company, a home or specific dates, property managers are one of the two biggest sources the engines cite.

What a property manager would do differently: instead of treating AI search as one thing, decide which stage each page is for, and know who it is up against there.

How we know: 123,695 citations from 19,950 answers. Every cited website was reviewed one at a time and put in a category, not sorted by a rule of thumb.

Where do property managers beat OTAs?

Here is the managers-against-OTAs contest on its own, stage by stage.

Property managers and OTAs, side by side at each stage of the trip

Share of the sources cited at each stage, each engine weighted equally. A tie is within 2 points.

Property managers lead at 3 stages, tie at 1, and OTAs lead at 4.

Property managersOTAs
Where to goOTAs lead
5%
12%
Things to do and trip planningProperty managers lead
10%
6%
Which area to stay inOTAs lead
9%
18%
Which company or kind of placeProperty managers lead
36%
21%
A home for my groupTie
31%
30%
Several needs stacked in one askOTAs lead
19%
50%
Dates or a budgetProperty managers lead
41%
34%
Long, the way guests talkOTAs lead
18%
44%

Base: 123,695 citations from 19,950 answers, five engines, 50 markets. November 14 to 16, 2026. A snapshot; AI answers change.

Property managers got more citations than OTAs at three of the eight stages, tied at one, and trailed at four.

Where property managers lead:

  • Which company or kind of place to book: property managers 36% of citations, OTAs 21%.
  • Questions with dates or a budget: property managers 41% of citations, OTAs 34% (each engine weighted equally).
  • Things to do and trip planning: property managers 10% of citations, OTAs 6%.

Where they tie: a home for my group, property managers 31% of citations, OTAs 30%.

Where OTAs lead:

  • Where to go: OTAs 12% of citations, property managers 5%.
  • Which area to stay in: OTAs 18% of citations, property managers 9%.
  • Several needs stacked in one ask (pet friendly, sleeps 12, hot tub): OTAs 50% of citations, property managers 19%.
  • Long questions written the way guests talk: OTAs 44% of citations, property managers 18%.

What it means: property managers already win the moment a guest is choosing who to book with. OTAs win the questions that read like a search filter. Our read on why: a question with four requirements looks like a filter, and an OTA has a listing for nearly every combination of filters in a market.

What a property manager would do differently: instead of competing with OTAs on every question, put the effort where property managers already lead or tie: a clear answer to “vacation rental companies in [your town]”, pages for group sizes and kinds of trips, and home pages that state plainly who each home fits. For which exact questions those are, see which guest questions property managers win.

Why is the planning stage worth going after?

Because the share is there, and OTAs barely compete for it. On “things to do” and trip planning questions, OTAs get 6% of citations. The big holders are travel blogs and media and tourism boards, and what the engines cite from them is guides.

The same is true when the engines cite a property manager on a planning question. In those cases, 84% of the cited pages we could read were a guide, blog post or area page (683 property manager citations on planning questions).

What it means: at the planning stage, the engines cite guides. That is share a property manager can take, since a property manager who lives in the market can write that kind of page.

What a property manager would do differently: instead of skipping the planning stage because travel blogs and tourism boards hold most of it today, write the local guides only a local can write: best time to visit, what to know before you go, which part of town fits which kind of trip.

If you have read our earlier research: with 50 markets and every cited site reviewed one at a time, not by a rule of thumb, property managers get 9% of citations on planning questions (7,552 citations, all five engines pooled).

Do all five AI engines recommend the same sites?

No. The five engines behave like five different markets.

Who each AI engine cites, across all 1,330 questions

Each bar adds to 100% of that engine's citations.

Property managersOTAsNational rental brands and travel search sitesHotels, resorts, innsTravel blogs and mediaTourism boards and governmentAttractions and local businessesSocial sites and forumsOther
ChatGPTcites a property manager in 39% of answers
30%26%10%17%
Geminicites a property manager in 73% of answers
29%28%12%11%
Perplexitycites a property manager in 40% of answers
10%46%11%11%9%
AI Overviewscites a property manager in 58% of answers
25%12%9%8%27%
Claudecites a property manager in 41% of answers
24%23%14%21%
See the numbers
EngineProperty managersOTAsNational rental brands and travel search sitesHotels, resorts, innsTravel blogs and mediaTourism boards and governmentAttractions and local businessesSocial sites and forumsOtherAnswers citing a property managerAnswers citing an OTASources per answer
ChatGPT30%26%6%4%10%17%2%1%3%39%38%3.1
Gemini29%28%12%5%11%8%3%3%2%73%69%7.6
Perplexity10%46%11%1%11%9%2%6%3%40%91%10.0
AI Overviews25%12%7%9%8%6%5%27%2%58%45%6.8
Claude24%23%14%3%21%5%3%5%2%41%46%3.5

Base: 19,950 answers, 123,695 citations. November 14 to 16, 2026. A snapshot; AI answers change.

  • Gemini is the most generous to property managers. It cited at least one property manager in 73% of its answers.
  • Perplexity leans hardest on OTAs. OTAs got 46% of its citations. It cited at least one OTA in 91% of its answers.
  • Google AI Overviews lean on social sites and forums, which got 27% of their citations.
  • ChatGPT gave tourism boards a bigger share of its citations than any other engine (17% of its citations across all 1,330 questions), and Claude gave travel blogs and media about double the other engines’ share (21%).

Lodging answers, engine by engine

On lodging questions only, here is how each engine’s answers split between property managers and OTAs (about 1,100 lodging answers per engine per day, each row adds to 100%):

  • ChatGPT: property manager only 23%, OTA only 23%, both 22%, neither 32%.
  • Gemini: property manager only 16%, OTA only 17%, both 60%, neither 7%.
  • Perplexity: property manager only 3%, OTA only 55%, both 40%, neither 2%.
  • Google AI Overviews: property manager only 27%, OTA only 16%, both 34%, neither 24%.
  • Claude: property manager only 17%, OTA only 24%, both 26%, neither 33%.

Google AI Overviews cited a property manager and no OTA in more lodging answers than any other engine. Perplexity cited an OTA and no property manager in more than half of its lodging answers.

What it means: a property manager can look strong on one engine and nearly absent on another. Testing one engine tells you little about the rest.

What a property manager would do differently: instead of asking ChatGPT once and assuming the rest match, ask all five engines the questions that matter in your market, and note which ones name you and which ones send the guest to an OTA.

How we know: 19,950 answers, 1,330 questions per engine per day, every cited website reviewed one at a time.

What should a property manager take from this?

The contest with OTAs is not lost, and it is not one contest. Property managers lead when guests ask what to do, pick a company or give dates; tie on a home for a group; and trail on where to go, which area to stay in, stacked asks and long questions. At the planning stage the engines cite guides, and that is share a property manager can take with its own.

For how search position on Google and Bing fits in, read is AI search different from SEO?. For the full picture, see our guide to AI search for vacation rentals.

Frequently asked questions

Do OTAs dominate AI search for vacation rentals?

Not everywhere. Property managers got more citations than OTAs when guests asked which company to book, gave dates or a budget, or asked what to do. OTAs led on where to go, which area to stay in, stacked asks and long, detailed questions. The two tied on a home for a group.

Where do property managers win in AI search?

At the shopping stage. On “which company or kind of place” questions, property managers got 36% of citations and OTAs 21%. On questions with dates or a budget, property managers got 41% and OTAs 34%, with each engine weighted equally. OTAs led on where to go, which area to stay in, stacked asks and long questions.

Who gets cited on trip-planning questions?

Mostly travel blogs and media and tourism boards. On “things to do” questions, tourism boards got 29% of citations and OTAs 6%. When a property manager was cited, it was usually for a local guide.

Which AI engine recommends property managers most?

Google Gemini cited at least one property manager in 73% of its answers. Perplexity leaned most on OTAs, which got 46% of its citations.

Do I need to check every AI engine separately?

Yes. The five engines cite very different mixes of websites. On lodging questions, Perplexity cited an OTA and no property manager in 55% of answers. Google AI Overviews cited a property manager and no OTA in 27%.

Want to know how the AI engines answer for your market? Book a call and we will walk through what each engine says about your area, and where property managers are winning against the OTAs there.

Book a call
Scroll to Top