Bringing Luxury Hotel Standards to Short Term Rentals with Moira Sedgwick
“We know we can’t be there to get guests what they need, so we’re constantly thinking—what do they need? What will they think they need, and how can we have it there before they know they need it?” In this episode of Booked Solid, Moira Sedgwick shares how years of working with luxury hotel chains and the James Beard Awards shaped her approach to short-term rentals. You’ll discover why thinking like a boutique hotel operator—not just a host—can transform your guest experience and market positioning. Moira walks through her framework for designing spaces that feel like a “wealthy auntie’s home,” how to audit your property through a hospitality lens, and why the details guests notice most are often the ones you overlook. Whether you’re launching your first property or scaling a portfolio, this conversation reveals what it takes to stand out in saturated markets. Summary and Highlights 🏨 Meet Moira Sedgwick Moira Sedgwick is the founder of A Chalet Collective, a boutique hospitality firm that designs and hosts short- and mid-term rentals, and Moca Interiors, the design studio behind each property’s distinctive look and feel. She’s been hosting since 2013 and brings a lifetime of hospitality expertise, including her role leading operations for the James Beard Awards. Moira owns and manages her own properties while partnering with homeowners and investors to create high-performing rentals that feel less like listings and more like curated stays. Her training at the Culinary Institute of America and years working with luxury hospitality brands inform her meticulous approach to design, service, and guest experience. Guided by values of artful design, warmth, and thoughtful curation, Moira delivers spaces that inspire guests and generate strong returns for owners. 🎯 Key Takeaways Design isn’t decoration—it’s strategy. Moira approaches every project by asking clients which hotel brand they want to emulate. This helps set expectations around quality, budget, and guest avatar before a single piece of furniture is selected. Hospitality happens in the details. Without staff on-site, short-term rentals must anticipate needs through design. Extra pillows in different firmness levels, outlets by the bedside, fully stocked kitchens—these small touches communicate care and elevate reviews. You’re competing with hotels, not just other rentals. Guests compare your property to branded hotels with massive marketing budgets and trained staff. Moira’s solution? Deliver hotel-level standards through thoughtful systems, quarterly property audits, and a relentless focus on the guest journey. Market positioning starts with self-awareness. Before worrying about amenities or aesthetics, ask yourself: what hotel chain are you? A Motel 6 or a Ritz-Carlton? Your answer shapes everything from sheet quality to the type of guest you attract. Quality compounds over time. Investing in organic cotton sheets and cast iron cookware isn’t just about luxury—it’s about longevity, guest satisfaction, and building a reputation that drives repeat bookings. Moira calls it “wealthy auntie energy,” and it works. 🛏️ From James Beard to Boutique Rentals: Moira’s Hospitality Philosophy Moira didn’t stumble into hosting. As a kid, she played pretend bed-and-breakfast, crafting imaginary breakfasts for guests. Years later, she stayed at a Portland B&B with self-check-in—no host on-site, but impeccable hospitality. When Airbnb launched, she recognized the opportunity immediately. Her career foundation came from the Culinary Institute of America, where she learned that hosting people—whether at a table, in a hotel, or at a rental—can genuinely impact lives. She worked in kitchens, consulted with luxury hospitality brands, and directed the James Beard Awards. Those experiences taught her how to layer service, storytelling, and attention to detail into every guest interaction. Today, that philosophy shapes how she approaches direct booking strategies. Moira sees each space as a lifestyle experience, not just a place to sleep. Guests should feel like they’re staying with a wealthy relative who has exquisite taste, not renting a commoditized listing. Everything from the coffee station—complete with pour-over instructions via QR code—to the pillow options reflects this mindset. She emphasizes that short-term rental operators face a unique challenge. Hotels have staff to adapt service in real time. STR hosts don’t. So the property itself must communicate hospitality through design, amenities, and thoughtful systems. As Moira puts it, “We can’t be there to change out your pillows, so we better have soft and firm options already available.” 🏡 The “Wealthy Auntie” Framework: Designing for Warmth and Aspiration One of Moira’s most memorable metaphors is designing properties to feel like a “wealthy auntie’s home.” It’s not about opulence for its own sake. It’s about warmth, quality, and the small indulgences that make a stay feel special. Think antique rugs that have stories. Le Creuset pans that have weight and history. Organic cotton sheets that feel luxurious. Scented soaps (or unscented, for guests with sensitivities). These aren’t just design choices—they’re signals that someone cared enough to think through every detail. When Moira consults with new clients, she often encounters resistance. Why spend extra on high-quality items when guests might not notice? Her answer is simple: they will notice. Maybe not consciously, but the cumulative effect of quality decisions shapes how guests feel about their stay. That feeling shows up in reviews, repeat bookings, and word-of-mouth referrals. She shared a story about staying at a beautiful waterfront property that looked stunning in photos but failed in execution. No wine openers. Poorly stocked kitchen. Basics missing. The property was coasting on location alone, and Moira’s group felt let down. That’s the opposite of her philosophy. Whether a guest cooks every meal or never touches the kitchen, the tools should be there—and they should be good. For hosts serious about building their direct booking websites, Moira’s approach offers a blueprint. Start by identifying your guest avatar. Are you attracting Motel 6 guests or Ritz-Carlton guests? Your answer dictates everything from your marketing to your amenity choices. Then audit your property through that lens. Does every touchpoint align with the experience you’re promising? 🔍 Walking Through the Guest Journey: Why Property Audits Matter Moira and her team conduct quarterly audits of every property they manage. Not just cleanliness checks—full guest experience










