Guest Retargeting Direct Bookings: 400% Revenue Growth with Sam Mistretta
Airbnb just changed everything with their new fee structure—and most hosts are sleepwalking into smaller profits. In this episode of Booked Solid, Sam Mistretta returns to share what he’s learned after 18 months in the trenches helping hosts drive repeat bookings through text and email marketing. Sam built a system that grew his own direct booking revenue by 400%, and his company, Go STR Marketing, now helps hosts achieve an average 650% ROI on their guest retargeting campaigns. We break down why authentic, personal communication outperforms corporate branding, why coupon codes aren’t the magic bullet you think they are, and the one rental agreement strategy that’s still flying under Airbnb’s radar. Whether you’re a new host or managing dozens of properties, this conversation will shift how you think about guest relationships and building a direct booking business that compounds over time. Summary and Highlights 🎙️ Meet Sam Mistretta Sam Mistretta is the founder of Go STR Marketing, a company that helps short-term rental hosts bring past guests back through strategic text and email campaigns. His journey began in 2022 when he left his corporate IT career to focus full-time on the short-term rental business he and his wife had built. With 18 properties and roughly 1,000 past guest contacts sitting in his PMS, Sam knew the easiest revenue was waiting in his existing database. When he couldn’t find an affordable solution to market to those guests, he built one himself. The result? A 400% increase in direct booking revenue within the first year. Word spread through his mastermind group, STR Secrets, and Go STR Marketing was born. Today, his team helps hosts achieve an average ROI of 650% while consistently beating hospitality industry benchmarks by over 700%. 🌊 The Airbnb Shift Every Host Needs to Understand The short-term rental landscape has changed dramatically. Lead times are shrinking. Competition is fiercer. And Airbnb has made sweeping policy changes that directly impact your bottom line. Sam and Gil walked through the major shifts: The new fee structure moves hosts from paying roughly 3% to now covering 15-15.5% in commissions. For a $200 nightly booking, that translates to a 12.9% reduction in earnings overnight if you don’t adjust your pricing. Airbnb’s communication changes now mask phone numbers, limiting your ability to contact guests to just two days after checkout. Chargeback policies now push disputed payments back onto hosts. And the platform continues tightening control over how you interact with guests. Sam put it bluntly: if you’re sleeping on these changes and not adjusting your strategy, you’re going to make less money this year than last—even if your booking volume stays the same. 🏠 Why Authenticity Wins in Guest Marketing One of the most valuable insights from Sam’s data involves branding. Some hosts want to project a large, corporate image. Others sign off with their first name and a headshot. The data shows which approach actually converts. Personal, authentic campaigns consistently outperform corporate-style messaging. Signing off with your name, including a photo, and sharing why you became a host creates connection. Guests who had a great stay want to feel like they have someone on the inside—not a faceless booking entity. Gil confirmed seeing the same pattern on the website side. Properties with genuine host bios and photos show longer dwell times and lower bounce rates. Even larger property managers with 50+ doors see better results when they introduce their team and tell their story. It’s not about size. It’s about making guests feel like they’re booking with real people who care. 💡 The Coupon Code Reality Check Many hosts obsess over crafting the perfect discount offer. Sam’s data reveals something surprising: the majority of re-bookers don’t use coupon codes at all. When guests had a great experience, they don’t need a discount to come back. They book because they trust you. They feel like they’ve got a connection. The coupon becomes secondary to the relationship. This doesn’t mean coupons are useless—they still work well for acquisition through influencers or local partnerships. But for repeat guest marketing, the emphasis should be on maintaining that authentic connection rather than leading with discounts. 📈 Direct Bookings Compound Over Time Both Sam and Gil emphasized a fundamental truth: direct booking success doesn’t happen overnight. It builds momentum over time. Sam compared it to investing in the S&P 500. It’s not sexy at first. You won’t see instant results. But three or four years later, you’ll look back and realize you built something substantial. This stands in contrast to the Airbnb dopamine cycle—chasing the next booking notification, constantly adjusting rates to fill gaps. Direct booking strategy requires patience, consistency, and a long-term view. You’re building an email list. You’re refining your messaging. You’re learning what resonates with your audience. The hosts who invest in this approach now will be far better positioned than those scrambling to react when the next policy change hits. For those just getting started, building your email collection strategy should be a priority from day one. 🔧 Tactical Advice: The Rental Agreement Strategy Sam shared a specific tactic that remains compliant with Airbnb’s current policies: automated rental agreements. After a guest books through Airbnb, you can send an automated rental agreement through your PMS that collects their phone number and email. Sam was initially skeptical—another thing for guests to click seemed like friction. But out of roughly 2,000 bookings, only two guests pushed back. The key is disclosure. Make sure your listing mentions that a rental agreement will be required. And if you plan to reach out to guests off-platform, Sam recommends waiting at least 15 days after their departure. Why? The post-stay review survey expires at the 14-day mark, reducing the risk of any policy enforcement. 📱 Why Your Website Matters for Co-Hosting Growth The conversation took an interesting turn when Sam shared a story about a client named Mike Munson. Mike had three verbal commitments from property owners ready to switch management companies. But when it came time to sign, they










