Direct Bookings in Short-Term Rentals: From 10% to 80% with Suzy Turnbull
“You have to really get under the cover of knowing who it is you’re trying to attract. If you don’t know that, you are not going to succeed.” — Suzy Turnbull How does a single-property host in Panama grow from 10% to 80% direct bookings in just over two years? In this episode of Booked Solid, Gil sits down with Suzy Turnbull, author of 5-Star Hosting Made Simple and a former marketing executive who turned her Buenaventura villa into a thriving direct booking business. Suzy shares the exact progression of her direct booking growth year by year, the infrastructure she wishes she’d built sooner, how a single conversation with Canadian birdwatchers reshaped her entire guest experience, and why hospitality — not just tactics — is the real engine behind repeat bookings. If you’re a host or property manager who wants to move beyond OTA dependency but doesn’t know where to start, this one’s for you. Summary and Highlights 🌱 Meet Suzy Turnbull Suzy Turnbull is the author of 5-Star Hosting Made Simple, a practical guidebook for independent short-term rental hosts with one to four properties. Her background is firmly rooted in marketing — she holds a Master’s in Digital Marketing from the IDM in London and has spent the last few years expanding her expertise into AI for marketing, with a focus on the practical use of generative AI tools for small business owners. Before becoming an author and consultant, Suzy spent seven years running a highly successful five-star short-term rental in Panama, Central America. She started with no prior industry experience, built the business from the ground up, and eventually moved it from hobby hosting into a full-fledged professional operation. Today, she combines that real-world hosting experience with her marketing expertise to help independent hosts simplify operations, build trust, and create standout guest experiences. Before our conversation, Gil and Suzy had met briefly, and it was clear almost immediately that she had packaged years of hard-won lessons into something genuinely useful for the industry. This episode is an attempt to unpack some of those lessons — especially the ones that helped her grow direct bookings from barely anything to 80% of total reservations. 💡 Why Direct Bookings in Short-Term Rentals Demand a Marketing Mindset One of the first things Suzy emphasized is that marketing isn’t a separate activity you bolt on once your site is live. It’s the foundation of the whole operation. And most hosts, she noted, shy away from it — not because they don’t care, but because it feels overwhelming. “They find it painful to think about how to do this,” Suzy told Gil. “Most people don’t know how to do that.” Her message throughout the conversation was that direct bookings in short-term rentals don’t happen because you built a nice website. They happen because you did the research, defined your ideal guest, understood your competition, and crafted a clear offer around a specific person you wanted to attract. Everything else follows from there. This echoes what CraftedStays has written about using your ideal guest avatar as an acquisition strategy — a decision that shapes every downstream choice you make. 📈 The Real Timeline: From 10% to 80% Direct Bookings Suzy walked Gil through the actual year-by-year progression of her direct booking growth, and this part is worth paying attention to because it’s refreshingly honest. Year one, roughly 10% of her bookings were direct. Year two, she hit around 30% — below her own target but steady. It was in the final six months of her operation that direct bookings jumped to 80%. And she was candid: sustaining 80% long-term would have been difficult. A more realistic mature state, she said, was probably 60–70%. What drove the acceleration? A combination of search visibility, Google Maps presence, guests finding her villa’s name in OTA listings and searching for it directly, and a growing pool of repeat bookers from Canada who loved escaping winter in Buenaventura. For hosts wondering how realistic direct booking growth looks, this guide on building a scalable direct booking strategy pairs nicely with Suzy’s real-world numbers. 🧱 The Infrastructure Suzy Wishes She’d Built Sooner Suzy’s biggest regret? Waiting six months to launch her direct booking website. She told Gil she missed real opportunity in those early months — and she wants other hosts to learn from it. Before accepting direct bookings, she laid down a few non-negotiables: On mobile especially, reducing friction is everything. CraftedStays’ PEF Framework for mobile booking covers what that looks like in practice. 🐦 The Birdwatcher Story (And What It Taught Her About Listening) One of the best moments in the conversation came when Suzy described a group of Canadian birdwatchers who stayed at her villa. They casually mentioned they’d spotted 40 bird species during their stay. Instead of filing that away as a cute anecdote, Suzy acted on it. She bought a bird-spotting telescope, stocked a bird guide, and created a downloadable “how many birds can you spot?” checklist. She wrote blog content around it. She leaned into a niche within her niche. That one piece of guest feedback turned into a durable marketing asset — and a clearer sense of who her property was actually for. Her advice to every host: read your reviews carefully. The sentiment is always there. And don’t stop at your own reviews. Look at two or three of your closest competitors’ reviews too. The nuggets hiding in there are genuinely useful for sharpening your positioning. 🛏️ The Smallest Change That Made the Biggest Difference When Suzy’s family decided to morph from hobby hosting into a full-time operation, they raised their standards. The simplest change they made? Upgrading to high-quality beds that could be configured as either twins or a king. It sounds trivial. It wasn’t. Guests loved being asked how they wanted the bed configured. It signaled hospitality. It signaled care. And it expanded who the property could realistically serve — from couples to families to friend groups — without changing a










