Destination Marketing Direct Bookings STR: Tapping Into Tourism Data with Jennifer Barbee
“Be so good they can’t ignore you. That’s where you are.” What if there was an entire organization in your county — funded partly by your own lodging taxes — dedicated to driving visitors to your destination, and you’ve never once reached out to them? In this episode of the Booked Solid Show, Gil sits down with Jennifer Barbee, tourism strategist and creator of the Host Gap™, to uncover a massive blind spot for short-term rental operators. Jennifer has worked with over 400 destinations across the U.S. and reveals how DMOs (Destination Marketing Organizations) hold a goldmine of traveler research, event calendars, and visitor data that most hosts have never tapped into. You’ll learn how independent lodging went from 4% of the market to nearly 30%, why that shift is changing everything, and how building a relationship with your local tourism office could reshape your direct booking strategy from the ground up. Summary and Highlights 👩💼 Meet Jennifer Barbee Jennifer Barbee is a tourism strategist with 30+ years of experience working inside and alongside destinations. She is the Co-Founder and CEO of Destination Innovate and creator of the Host Gap™ — a framework that names the disconnect between destination marketing organizations and the short-term rental hosts who now deliver a significant share of the visitor economy. Jennifer got her start in the late ’90s, accidentally becoming a programmer when the very first destination websites were being built. Before she turned 30, she had worked with over 400 destinations — from Las Vegas and Miami to smaller regional markets. Her career spans web development, advertising, audience research, and civic tourism strategy. Today, she’s focused on bridging the gap between DMOs and STR operators through her upcoming Hosts & Home Teams™ summit and her ongoing essays on LinkedIn’s The Daily Destruptor. 📊 From 4% to 30% — The Shift That Changed Everything One of the most striking numbers Jennifer shared: before 2020, independent lodging (short-term rentals, boutique hotels, B&Bs) accounted for roughly 4% of the U.S. lodging market. Today, that figure sits at nearly 30%. That explosion happened fast, and most destination marketing organizations weren’t prepared for it. Jennifer pointed out that DMOs were originally created by hoteliers—specifically as Convention and Visitors Bureaus— and funded through lodging taxes paid by hotels. Short-term rentals weren’t part of that equation. In many cases, they still aren’t fully integrated into the system. This is why so many cities and counties are scrambling to figure out regulations, representation, and how to work with independent operators. Jennifer’s take? It’s not a moral problem. It’s a systems problem. And solving it starts with getting hosts into the conversation. 🔑 What DMOs Have That You Don’t (But Should) Here’s where things get practical for operators thinking about their direct booking strategy. DMOs invest heavily in traveler research — the kind of data most independent hosts never see. Jennifer broke down what that includes: Who is visiting your destination, what are their demographics, and what are their travel patterns? What types of events and groups are coming each year? How repeat visitation compares across markets (Pigeon Forge, for example, sees about 75% repeat visitors, while Miami sees roughly 12%). Seasonal trends, spending data, and group travel behavior. This research doesn’t just help with marketing your properties — it can inform investment decisions, amenity choices, and even how you furnish your spaces. If you know your market draws families with kids who visit four times a year, that changes everything from your guest avatar to your email nurture sequences. 🏷️ The SMERF Market — A Hidden Goldmine for STR Hosts Jennifer introduced one of the episode’s most interesting concepts: the SMERF market. It stands for Social, Military, Educational, Religious, and Fraternal — and it refers to unmanaged group travel. Think quilting competitions, car shows, soccer tournaments, family reunions, and small niche conferences. These groups typically bring 10 to 50 people at a time. They travel more often, spend more money, and represent a huge opportunity for short-term rental operators — especially those who can accommodate multi-room bookings. The challenge? Most hosts don’t know these groups are coming because that data lives with the DMO. Jennifer emphasized that building a relationship with your destination’s tourism office can unlock exactly this kind of intelligence, giving you an edge in preparing your properties and tailoring your content marketing to attract these travelers. 🤝 How to Actually Reach Your Local DMO Jennifer offered straightforward advice on making that first connection. Look for the community management or community steward role at your local DMO — not the chamber of commerce (which may try to sell you advertising instead). Your destination marketing organization is usually the entity that collects the bed tax and may be called Visit [Your City], Experience [Your Region], or something similar. When you reach out, Jennifer recommended framing it this way: Introduce yourself as a host who loves the destination. Ask what traveler research or data they can share. Find out how you can better align with the types of travelers they’re attracting. Request any printed materials or visitor guides you can keep on-site for guests. It sounds simple, but Jennifer noted that most hosts have never taken this step. And the DMOs? They often don’t even know who you are — especially when OTAs like Airbnb remit taxes as lump sums without identifying individual properties. 🔄 Repeat Guests, Destination Identity, and the Direct Booking Connection Jennifer and Gil explored how understanding your destination’s repeat visitation rate completely changes your marketing approach. In a high-repeat market, your biggest opportunity is email capture and guest nurturing. In a low-repeat market, the focus shifts to discovery, social proof, and first-impression marketing. Jennifer also shared a powerful insight about direct booking guests versus OTA guests. A book-direct traveler tends to be less sophisticated, more loyal, and craving personalization. If you serve them well — learn their favorite coffee, remember their kids’ names, leave a small surprise — they don’t just come back. They post about it on










