Facebook Groups, Repeat Guests, and More: Scaling Direct Bookings Without Overcomplicated Systems with Sarah Pell
Ever wondered how to break free from OTAs and take control of your bookings? Sarah Pell did just that. She went from teaching elementary school to managing a thriving short-term rental portfolio using a mix of ownership, arbitrage, and co-hosting. In this episode of Direct Bookings Simplified, Sarah reveals the exact strategies she used to scale her business, build a strong direct booking system, and maximize profitability—without overcomplicated tech. Summary and Highlights Building a Portfolio with Three STR Strategies “Arbitrage really opened up my world. Just within a year and a half, I had acquired four. Compared to saving for a single purchase, it was a game-changer.” Sarah’s path to STR success wasn’t conventional. After getting into real estate through house hacking, she realized that long-term rentals weren’t providing the cash flow she wanted. Instead, she turned to vacation rentals. She initially purchased a condo in Orange Beach but quickly recognized that saving for down payments would take too long. That’s when she discovered rental arbitrage, allowing her to scale faster. Within a year and a half, Sarah went from one STR to four through arbitrage, while also co-hosting for other owners. Balancing ownership, arbitrage, and co-hosting has given her a well-rounded perspective on managing STRs and optimizing guest experiences. Direct Booking Strategies That Work Sarah emphasizes that while starting on platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo is essential, building direct bookings is what truly allows STR owners to scale. Here are some of the strategies that have worked for her: 1. Leveraging Facebook Groups for Direct Bookings One of Sarah’s biggest game-changers was tapping into Facebook groups to promote her listings. Instead of relying solely on Airbnb, she joined vacation rental and travel-related groups in her market. “I found that Facebook groups were like a secret sauce. I would join groups for vacation stays in my area and respond to travelers looking for dates with a direct booking link. That was a huge boost early on.” 2. Using Repeat Guests to Drive More Direct Bookings Sarah actively encourages repeat guests to book directly. She offers a 15% discount to returning guests who book through her direct website and includes promotional business cards and magnets inside her properties. “We text every guest after their stay with a promo code they can share with friends and family. It’s a simple way to encourage direct bookings.” 3. Capturing Guest Emails for Long-Term Success Sarah initially collected guest emails manually but later streamlined the process using her property management software. Her team now sends email campaigns and promotional offers to past guests through MailChimp. “Even before I had MailChimp, I was manually emailing past guests with BCC. You don’t need a fancy system to start—just start collecting emails.” 4. Setting Up a Strong Direct Booking Website While Sarah started with a simple site, she’s now investing in making it more streamlined and guest-friendly. She plans to integrate better search functionality and branding to make it easier for guests to find and book her properties. Automation vs. Personalization in Direct Bookings One key takeaway from Sarah’s journey is that automation is helpful, but personal connection matters. While she uses automated text and email follow-ups, she still handles guest communications manually to ensure a personal touch. “I still handle my guest messaging personally because I want to interact with them. It helps me understand their concerns and improve my guest experience.” Scaling Direct Bookings with the Right Tools Sarah’s experience shows that you don’t need a complex system to succeed with direct bookings—you just need the right mindset and simple, effective strategies. Whether you’re just getting started or looking to scale, her approach proves that taking small steps, like leveraging Facebook groups and collecting emails, can make a big impact. If you want to hear Sarah’s full journey and her step-by-step direct booking tactics, listen to the full episode of Direct Bookings Simplified [link to podcast episode]. Join the Community Want to connect with like-minded STR owners focused on direct bookings? Join our community, where we discuss strategies, share insights, and support each other in building sustainable short-term rental businesses. [Link to community] Looking to optimize your direct booking site? At CraftedStays, we help STR owners create high-converting, mobile-optimized direct booking websites. If you’re ready to take control of your bookings and maximize revenue, check out CraftedStays today. Follow Sarah Here ⤵️ Transcription Sarah: Part of my direct booking as well is Facebook groups. So I do have a business Facebook page and you wouldn’t even need to do a page. I’ve done it even just personally. And I will have a little message with my direct booking link. And so what I do is join these groups. So like, um, you know, vacation stays of orange beach, and I will go in there and I will look for people that are searching for dates to come and I will just copy and paste my little message about my condo and. I have found that was like a, in the beginning to a huge boost in like my direct bookings is I found that a lot of people would find me on Facebook and then reach out on my direct booking website. And so I would say that, uh, I feel like Facebook groups are kind of like a secret sauce. I mean, cause you can find co hosts, you know, arbitrage, properties, direct booking clients. Like it kind of, it’s all, all there. Gil: Hey folks, welcome back to direct booking simplified, where we break down the strategies and tactics to win in direct bookings. On today’s show, I have Sarah Pell. Sarah, welcome to the show. Sarah: Thank you, Gail, for having me. I’m excited to be here. Gil: Yeah. As we get into it, do you mind giving folks a quick introduction on who you are? Folks may have seen you on Instagram or other places, but yeah. Introduce yourself. Sarah: Yeah, of course. So, I’m originally from Pierce, South Dakota. That’s where I was born and










