Crafting Guest Loyalty Through Experiential Marketing with Dawn LaMattina Asher
Dawn LaMattina Asher is the founder and creative director of The Olive Jar, an experiential marketing studio focused on vacation rental design, amenities, and media content creation for visionary hosts. With 20 years of experience in experiential storytelling across entertainment media, hospitality, and brand marketing, Dawn helps hosts transform ordinary stays into unforgettable guest experiences that foster loyalty and connection. “Experiential marketing builds brand loyalty.” That’s the powerful truth Dawn shares in this value-packed conversation. More than good design or amenities, what your guests feel during their stay creates lasting emotional bonds with your brand. We dive deep into what makes a stay memorable and how those emotional experiences convert into direct bookings and repeat guests. 🔍 Key Takeaways for Direct Booking Success 1. Experiences = Loyalty“The stronger the bond, the longer they’re gonna stick with you. That’s brand loyalty.” Emotion is the anchor of memory. Dawn shows how sensory-driven design and subtle storytelling throughout a home can turn guests into lifelong fans. 2. Co-host Marketing PitfallsMany co-hosts or management companies claim they offer marketing, but it often stops at SEO and pricing tools. According to Dawn, “Marketing is so much more than social media.” 3. Brand Clarity Before DesignBefore even placing a bed frame, hosts should define their brand voice and ideal guest. Dawn’s team creates branding guides that set the emotional tone for the entire guest journey. 4. Visuals Are Non-NegotiablePhotography and videography aren’t just visual assets—they’re storytelling tools. Dawn emphasizes, “We’re never layering in amenities without thinking how it’s going to be photographed.” 5. Give Guests a VoiceOne of her favorite tools? A dog guestbook where owners write from their pet’s point of view. “When you give someone a voice, they suddenly have ownership over the experience.” 🧠 Rapid Fire Questions 📚 Book Recommendation: JOYFUL: The Surprising Power of Ordinary Things to Create Extraordinary Happiness by Ingrid Fetell Lee 🧭 Mindset Advice: “Generosity is generative.” 🛠 Tactical Tip for Direct Bookings: Know the story you’re trying to tell. You have seconds to make that first impression on your site. 📲 Follow Dawn Here: Want to stop relying solely on OTAs? This episode is a masterclass in connecting your design and storytelling to build brand equity. If you’re ready to invest in your guest journey, you’re not alone. 👉 Join the CraftedStays community for more episodes, resources, and personalized support on your direct booking strategy. Let your next guest feel something worth remembering. And if you loved this episode, share it or tag us with your top takeaway! 💬 Transcription Dawn: A phrase I haven’t mentioned yet, but is wildly an important part of this. It’s really the core of what we’re doing is that experiential marketing builds brand loyalty. And as you invite and engage your guests into the experience that they want to create, right, they’re building a bond to your brand. Dawn: The stronger the bond, the longer they’re gonna stick with you. That’s brand loyalty. It’s a lifetime. It’s a relationship that is built over a lifetime. I say that emotions are the essential to connectedness and hosts who lean into that, they’re gonna build a loyal following. Gil: Hey folks. Welcome back to the Bo Solid Show, the podcast where we bring on top operators to discuss marketing, revenue management, and guest experiences to drive towards being Bo solid. On today’s show, I have Don LaMattina Asher. She’s the owner of the Olive Jar and STR consulting firm that specializes on crafting lasting guest experiences. Gil: On today’s show, we have a very fun show, really talking about experiential marketing, which is really her focus. We talk about really the entire guest journey and how we can really think intently. About the experiences that your guests want to have and turning that to really crafting that through seating. Gil: we also talk quite a bit about the importance of some of those smaller details. We went into great depth, much more than I would have expected on this show, so I’m really excited to have her on. So without further ado, let’s bring her in. Gil: Hey Dawn, welcome to the show. Dawn: Hi, . Great to be here. Thank you for the invite. Gil: Yeah, I’m so happy to have you on the show. For folks listening in, this is Dawn Laina Asher. I met her at Level Up Your listing and I, we just had a follow up conversation and we just really hit it off. So I’m really happy to have her on and really share really what she’s doing specifically in our industry. Gil: But I would love for you, Dawn, to introduce yourself. Who are you? Dawn: Yeah. So yeah, I am the founder and creative director of the Olive Jar. We are an experiential marketing studio, special specializing in vacation rental design amenities and media content creation. And we say for visionary hosts, because the work that we’re doing, um, is quite nuanced. And so we work with hosts who are really thinking on a, on a different, uh, in a different dimension of hosting. Dawn: And that layer of connectivity with their guests and their traveler, um, that really is, is not, uh, the status quo. So we say visionary host and we really pride ourselves in that. Gil: Yeah, and I think like nowadays, at least the folks that I’m starting to, to be surrounded with are hosts that are actually graduating from just seeing the properties as investment vehicles and they’re trying to build stronger brands and they’re trying to be a lot more independent from the OTAs as part of that. Gil: So I’m guessing that you’re actually starting to see a shift in the industry towards being that visionary host or trying to like get towards that in, in some phase. I’m not sure if you see the same trend on your side. Dawn: Oh yes, for sure. And, and I, I love it. I’m, I’m, I’m all for it. And,










